Efficient Release Strategies for Aphid Natural Enemies in Flower Crops Progress Report — September 1996
Date:8/30/96
Title of Project: Efficient release strategies of natural enemies
in flower crops.
Institution where work is being conducted: Texas A&M
Amount of Endowment Grant:
Covering Period:1/96 to 7/96
Anticipated Date of Project Completion /Final Report:
Individual(s) Conducting Project:
(List Project Leader First)
Dr. Kevin Heinz
Telephone Number:
Flower Crops.
Preface: Many of the past successes in biological control have
depended upon the identification and introduction of novel natural enemies
for a particular peg. The extremely low tolerances to arthropod damage
associated with floral crops grown for their aesthetic qualities suggest
that inundative releases of high rates of natural enemies are necessary
for successful biological Control of insect pests. Although releases of
natural enemies have produced excellent biological control of several insect
pests of greenhouse crops, this technique has not been widely embraced
by growers of ornamental plants due to the prohibitive costs associated
with maintaining post densities at extremely low levels, In response to
this problem, many researchers continue to search for natural enemies that
may be more effective than their present counterparts in hopes that a more
effective natural enemy will reduce costs. While this approach may eventually
be successful, it has not yet proven to be an effective approach to biological
control of insect pests of floral crops. My research takes another approach,
one that assumes that at least some of the many commercially available
natural enemies will be economical and effective if produced and utilized
in an optimal manner. The approach of my research funded by the American
Floral Endowment has been to develop efficient release strategies to bring
about economically feasible aphid biological control infesting chrysanthemums.
Project Objectives:
1. Assess how natural enemies locate and exploit patches of aphids
on chrysanthemums,
2. Determine natural enemy efficacy once they have located an aphid
infested plant.
3. Conduct Greenhouse trials to compare efficacy of each release strategy.
Summary of Results to Date: We have been able to Demonstrate
that so-called trivial movements of natural enemies may be used to improve
the efficacy of augmentative biological control of aphids infested potted
chrysanthemums based upon our results from several experiments. First,
we have studied how trivial movements of the green peach aphid, Myzuspersicae,
generate spa” heterogeneity within greenhouse cropping systems. Second,
we have documented how foraging patterns of the grow lacewing, Chrysoperla
carnea, and aphid parasitoid, Aphidius colemani, are influenced by the
spatial heterogeneity associated with their prey or hosts. These foraging
movements are of practical concern because they may influence the success
with which natural enemies regulate past populations. Chrysoperla carnea
is incapable of responding to changing spew patterns of aphid outbreaks
and is hence unable, to control aphids with weekly releases of the predator,
Aphidius colemani Is capable of locating and inflicting high rates of parasitism
on high and moderate density patches of aphids, but the parasitoid is unable
to locate low density patches. When wasps are released weekly, then low
aphid density patches develop into superabundant aphid patches between
parasitoid releases. Superabundant patches, which exhibit exponential population
growth, cannot be brought under biological control regardless of the wasp
release rates used. Currently we are conducting greenhouse trials to determine
whether we can prevent the formation of superabundant aphid patches using
one of two methods: (1) using an even greater number of wasp release points
within a greenhouse for a specified wasp release rate, and (2)
reducing the time period between wasp releases.
Future Plans Covered by the Endowment Grant: The information
obtained from this research yields a clear picture as to ways natural enemies
move through spatially and temporally heterogeneous greenhouse environments
and will form the bases for the development of optimal release strategies.
A next step of this research will be to generate these strategies and to
test their abilities to biologically control aphids in commercial chrysanthemum
production greenhouses.
Anticipated Benefits to the Floral Industry: The development
of non-chemical methods of arthropod pest control continually ranks as
a top research priority for the floral industry. In response to ties demand,
research on the use of parasitoids, predators and pathogens for arthropod
pest control has spurred tremendous growth in the commercial availability
of biological control agents. Unfortunately, scientific data necessary
to develop effective and economically feasible biological control programs
have not kept pace with the growth of the industry. Simply stated, the
research community is currently unable to provide scientifically based
recommendations to the floral industry as to the efficacious and cost effective
use of most, if not all, of the commercially available natural enemies
for use in floricultural crops. Biological control remains very much an
art form rather than a reliable technology. At the completion of my multiyear
project, I will have made significant advances in correcting this problem
for at log one major pest of floricultural crops. Current benefits already
include, (1) delineation of maximum aphid densities at which biological
control ran be expected to be effective, (2) quantification of parasitoid
release strategies that may lead to successful biological control, and
(3) comparison of the relative abilities of natural enemy species to bring
about successful biological control.
Presentations and Publications on Research Applicable to the Floral
Industry:
Heinz, K.M. 1996. A review of Liriomyza leafminers and a potential
new pest species, L. huidobrensis. Texas Greenhouse Bulletin. May, 1996.
pp. 8-9.
Heinz. K.M., L.M. Heinz, & M.P. Parrella. 1996. Natural enemies
of western flower thrips indigenous to California ornamentals. Integrated
Control in Glasshouses. IOBC/WPRS Bulletin (Vienna, Austria). 19(l): 51-54.
Heinz, K.M. 1996. Predators and parasitoids as biological control agents
of Bemisia in greenhouses. pp, 435-449.7 In (D. Gerling & R. Mayer,
eds,)Bemisia 1995: Taxonomy, biology, damage, control and management. Intercept,
Hants.
Heinz, K.M. 1996. ‘Movement and Foraging by Aphid Natural Enemies:
Oversimplification of the Functional Response” Pacific Branch of the Entomological
Society of America. Symposium on the Biorational/Biological Control Strategies
for Greenhouse Grown Crops N%ft-
